NCHC to review Adam Benák's slash on Cody Croal

The final seconds of a hockey game can be charged with emotion, but what unfolded late in Saturday’s contest between the University of North Dakota Fighting Hawks and Western Michigan Broncos raised concerns beyond the usual competitive fire. With just 2:03 left on the clock and UND leading 4-1, a slash by Western Michigan’s Adam Benák on UND forward Cody Croal sparked a brief melee and now faces review by the National Collegiate Hockey Conference (NCHC). This incident, while seemingly fleeting, underscores the fine line between fierce competition and potentially dangerous play in a sport known for its speed and physicality.

What Happened

The slash occurred as Cody Croal put the puck into an empty net to solidify UND’s 4-1 win over Western Michigan. Benák, Western Michigan's top-line center, took a one-handed swing with his stick that caught Croal in the neck. The UND junior forward immediately dropped behind the net. A melee ensued. Croal eventually got up, skated to Benák, and yelled at him. NCHC officials called a five-minute major and a game misconduct after video review. A game misconduct triggers an automatic ejection from the game but does not automatically result in a suspension, which will be determined following league review.

The NCHC’s standard procedure dictates that all five-minute major penalties are reviewed for potential supplemental discipline. NCHC commissioner Heather Weems and director of officiating Mike Schmitt attended Saturday night's game. Following the incident, Croal was unable to attend the postgame press conference because he was receiving medical treatment.

While the immediate aftermath involved a brief confrontation, the larger implications of Benák's actions will be considered by the league. It is a reminder of the inherent risks in a fast-paced sport like hockey and the importance of maintaining control even in the heat of competition. The incident occurred after Croal had leveled Benák along the boards earlier in the game, forcing a turnover that led to Croal's first goal of the night; Reschny kept the puck in the zone after the turnover and passed it to Gavin Lindberg, who fed Croal in the slot. Croal flipped a backhand past Western Michigan goaltender Quentin Miller for his fourth goal of the season.

Community Reaction

Coach Jackson’s Remarks

UND coach Dane Jackson acknowledged the severity of the slash, but expressed his belief that Benák is not a “dirty player.” He characterized the incident as a “reckless stick,” emphasizing that it appeared to be an accidental sweep at the puck rather than a malicious intent. He reiterated his belief that Benák was not trying to injure Croal.

Anthony Menghini, UND senior forward, shared his disappointment with the incident, calling it a “cheap shot” after Croal had already scored. However, he also expressed pride in his teammates for stepping in to defend Croal. “Sometimes, emotions get high, but to see our guys step in... I’m glad our teammates stepped up.”

Cody Croal’s Performance

Despite the incident, Cody Croal had a standout performance, recording a career-best three points with two goals and an assist. He is now tied as UND’s second-leading scorer with eight points in nine games, trailing only captain Cole Reschny. His linemate, Gavin Lindberg, praised Croal's consistency and work ethic, describing him as someone who “always winning his battles” and is “really fun to play with.” After the game, Menghini awarded Croal the team’s warrior helmet as player of the game.

What’s Next

The NCHC will now conduct a thorough review of the incident, considering video evidence and potentially interviewing involved parties. The outcome of this review could range from no further action to a suspension for Benák. The league's decision will not only affect Benák's playing status but also send a message about the acceptable level of physicality within the conference.

Beyond the immediate disciplinary action, this incident serves as a reminder of the importance of sportsmanship and respect within collegiate athletics. It underscores the need for players to control their emotions and avoid reckless actions that could jeopardize the safety of their opponents.

UND fans, deeply committed to the Fighting Hawks’ success, will be closely watching the NCHC's decision and hoping for a resolution that prioritizes player safety and fair play.

Amina’s Take

Watching this incident unfold, it’s a stark reminder that even in the excitement of competition, we must prioritize the well-being of our young athletes. Cody Croal's injury, while thankfully not appearing to be severe, highlights the potential for harm when emotions run high and actions are careless. It’s easy to get caught up in the passion of the game, especially when it's a rivalry or a crucial moment, but ultimately, these young men are representing their universities and communities – and they have a responsibility to do so with integrity and respect.

What’s truly encouraging is the response from Croal’s teammates, who stepped in to defend him. That demonstration of loyalty and camaraderie speaks volumes about the values instilled within the UND hockey program. We often talk about the importance of strong families and stable communities, and it's wonderful to see those same principles reflected on the ice.

The NCHC’s review is crucial not just for determining Benák's fate, but also for sending a clear message about the acceptable boundaries of play. I hope that whatever decision is reached, it serves as a catalyst for a renewed focus on sportsmanship and safety within collegiate hockey. It’s a chance to remind everyone involved – players, coaches, and fans alike—that the true measure of success isn't just winning, but how we play the game.

Resources

For more information about the NCHC and its policies, visit NCHC website. Information about UND Athletics can be found at UND Athletics website. If you or someone you know is struggling with the emotional impact of a sports-related incident, reach out to a trusted friend, family member, or mental health professional.

The Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) offers resources and support for mental health concerns.

The Crisis Text Line provides free, 24/7 crisis support via text message. Text HOME to 741741.

The Suicide & Crisis Lifeline is available 24/7 by calling or texting 988.